Feedback: "Navigate backwards to a button" (Command Button Example, Test 6)

[IsaDC]

Description of Behavior

As I see it, we have two options:

1. Mark the output as failing or
2. Ask the tester to press the command sequence twice.

Test Setup

• Test File at Exact Commit: test-06-navigate-backwards-to-button-interaction-voiceover_macos.collected.html
• AT: VoiceOver for macOS (version Latest)
• Browser: Safari (version Latest)

Review Conflicts for "Navigate backwards to a button"

1. Unexpected Behaviors for "Shift+Control+Option+Command+J" Command

   • Tester louis4533 recorded output "Run Test Setup dimmed button " and noted "2 presses of Shift+Control+Option+Command+J were necessary to achieve the desired output. First press navigated forward and placed focus on the last element on the page (dimmed Run Test Setup button.) Second press correctly navigated backwards and placed focus on the previous control (Print Page button).".
   • Tester IsaDC recorded output "Run Test Setup dimmed button You are currently on a button. This item is dimmed. " and noted "After pressing the command sequence, VoiceOver jumps to the "Run Test Setup" button.".

[IsaDC]

@louis4533 As the test only instructs that the command should be pressed once, you have correctly indicated that upon doing so, VoiceOver fails against the assertions. To resolve result conflicts, we will remove your indication of unexpected behavior because it relates to pressing the command multiple times which is not in scope.

[jscholes]

@s3ththompson to look into why the app raised this as a conflict. We will then revisit. Note the related issues, #738 and #740.

[s3ththompson]

@jscholes I opened an issue here to answer this question and document the behavior: w3c/aria-at-app#435

[IsaDC]

Assertions have been unified and undesirable behaviours have been removed.