diff --git a/src/streams/SubscriptionsScreen.js b/src/streams/SubscriptionsScreen.js
index ad90546eaf8..9a88af92b2a 100644
--- a/src/streams/SubscriptionsScreen.js
+++ b/src/streams/SubscriptionsScreen.js
@@ -61,7 +61,7 @@ export default function SubscriptionsScreen(props: Props): Node {
     return [
       { key: 'Pinned', data: sortedSubscriptions.filter(x => x.pin_to_top) },
       { key: 'Unpinned', data: sortedSubscriptions.filter(x => !x.pin_to_top && x.in_home_view) },
-      { key: 'Muted', data: sortedSubscriptions.filter(x => !x.in_home_view) },
+      { key: 'Muted', data: sortedSubscriptions.filter(x => !x.pin_to_top && !x.in_home_view) },
     ];
   }, [subscriptions]);